All Quiet on Pilgrim and Main, But That Could Soon Change

The prominent corner of Pilgrim Road and Main Street is home to one of Falls' most talked about vacancies. Toppers Pizza is on hold, but other businesses are expressing interest.

The highly visible corner of Pilgrim Road and Main Street in Menomonee Falls has also been a highly discussed topic of conversation in the village.

For most of 2013, construction has halted on the landmark building on the corner of Pilgrim Road and Main Street. The exterior is complete, but the interior remains empty. In November, Patch reported that in the building, but that hasn't materialized.

At the time, CBRE Vice President Andrew Stefanich said Toppers would occupy the site in spring 2013. Toppers even picked up HVAC applications with the village, but the location and layout of the pizzeria just wasn’t right.

A village staffer said the proposed layout would have allowed passers-by a view into the kitchen through the large windows facing the intersection. It was suggested they locate in a far end of the building, or another location within the same shopping center. 

A representative from Toppers Pizza World Headquarters said Tuesday that the company is still interested in locating in that shopping center, but the plans have been temprarily put on hold. 

Curiosity from residents was further piqued when Schlotzsky’s Deli owner Dan Gorman closed up shop. The closing left two prominent vacancies in an area long targeted for major improvements. However, it seems there could be light at the end of the tunnel — and plenty more intrigue.

"Yes, we’ve had a significant amount of interest and are very close on a few potential deals there,” Stefanich wrote in an email to Patch Tuesday. “We should be in a position to discuss in a few weeks.  If you reach back out to me mid-May, I should be able to let you know more.”

Community Development Director Matt Carran also said a proposed tenant for the landmark building was in Village Hall picking up applications. Another business was also inquiring about Schlotzky’s, but no official permit requests have been submitted at this point. Carran said they cannot disclose the name of those businesses until an official application is received by the village.

In 2011, the village advanced a , as well as a right of way land purchase on that corner site. The $620,000 right-of-way purchase allows for future expansion of Pilgrim Road. The village also advanced $200,000 to buffer costs resulting from environmental remediation needed on the gas station site.

Patch will continue to bring more updates as they are released regarding that particular corner of the village. 

lu April 25, 2013 at 03:33 AM
I asked some time ago and I was told that the Pilgrim Road redo that I read about a few years ago is not going to happen and that a new or redesigned interchange is years away in planning.
lu April 25, 2013 at 03:40 AM
I wish we had just one nice simple sit down restaurant for a business lunch with quality food. No french fries please, that's for the fast food place and crowd.
Nanc April 25, 2013 at 02:18 PM
Jann- I'm curious as well about the Pilgrim road expansion and what the plans are. I live on Main street and Lord knows, there's already enough traffic there and speeds are not policed at all. The speed limit is 25, but no one adheres to that.
Heather April 28, 2013 at 04:02 PM
Rather see an indie coffee shop than an Alterra-- or is that just a dream of John Harbor's gone by?
bruce springsteen April 30, 2013 at 11:48 PM
Nancy, this is clearly a beneficial action of our taxes. I hear they are planning on expanding main street as well inhibiting remy space but allowing more traffic to come from brown deer and milwaukee which I cannot find anything negative pertaining to that either. Plus! Everybody will have less lawn to mow. Yayyyyy!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »