This post was contributed by a community member. The views expressed here are the author's own.

Politics & Government

Two Different States, Two Different Budgets

To confirm that we did the right things here in Wisconsin, all we need to do is look to our neighbors to the south.

I noted with interest a recent Chicago Tribune article entitled, “Illinois budget deficit to hit $8 billion despite tax increase”. As I read the article, I could not help but to think of the dramatically different way in which our two states addressed our budget deficits – and how the results can teach us lasting lessons in budgeting and public policy.

I’ve spoken at great length in recent months about the measures we took here in Wisconsin in order to balance a budget with a $3.6 billion deficit. We did it through controlling spending and setting priorities. In addition, we made important reforms that allow state and local units of government more flexibility in addressing budget crises – and we did it all without raising taxes. 

They were not easy decisions, but they were absolutely necessary in order to get our budget out of its perpetual state of chaos and imbalance.

Find out what's happening in Menomonee Fallswith free, real-time updates from Patch.

Now, when I see how Illinois is handling its own budget crisis, I see a lot of similarities between what legislators and the governor are doing there and what we used to do here. As you may recall, our previous administration raised taxes under the 2009-11 state budget by $2 billion, with much of that total coming down on job creators. Additional policies were enacted that some experts estimated would cost Wisconsin $1 billion in higher property taxes.

These tax hikes had two major consequences. First, they caused a great number of businesses and jobs to flee Wisconsin. Second, they did nothing to address our ongoing budget crisis.  By listening to their rhetoric, you would have thought all of those tax increases would have solved all of our problems going forward, but they didn’t. Higher taxes made the problem worse – and from that came the $3.6 billion deficit we were forced to deal with earlier this year.

Find out what's happening in Menomonee Fallswith free, real-time updates from Patch.

That is why I’m mystified at Illinois’ desire to continue down that same path. Earlier this year, that state raised taxes on both individuals and businesses.  Lawmakers in the “Land of Lincoln” raised their individual income tax from three percent to five percent, a 66 percent overall increase. Similarly, they raised their corporate tax from 7.3 percent to 9.5 percent, which is now the fourth-highest state corporate income tax rate in America.

What was the result? 

Illinois’ state budget, just months after these new taxes were approved, is now in the red by $8.3 billion. According to the Chicago Tribune article, “The majority of that money, roughly $5.5 billion, will come in the form of unpaid bills from companies that provide everything from meals for the elderly to toilet paper for prisoners.  Another $1.2 billion is composed of Medicaid payments the state will push off until the next budget year, while the remaining $1.6 billion is owed to companies for tax returns and health insurance bills for state workers.”  Sound familiar?

Meanwhile, with a solvent state budget of our own, we continue to hear about local municipalities and school districts here in Wisconsin who are resolving budget crises. Because of our needed reforms, some are even reducing their property tax levies, providing needed relief to financially-strapped taxpayers.

The changes we’ve enacted in Wisconsin have, without a doubt, been controversial. But there is no question that they were needed and that they solved a large state problem. To confirm that we did the right things, all we need to do is look to our neighbors to the south.

To contact me with any questions or comments or to sign up for my regular e-updates, please send an e-mail to Rep.Knodl@legis.wi.gov or call me at (608) 266-3796.

We’ve removed the ability to reply as we work to make improvements. Learn more here

The views expressed in this post are the author's own. Want to post on Patch?