How Deeply Held is Anti-Muslim Sentiment and What is the Danger?

This takes a look at relations between the suburban communities and the expanding Muslim communities.

Over the weekend of March 13, an article appeared in the Brookfield Patch written by Rory Linnane titled: . The gist was that the Eagle Forum of Wisconsin was meeting to rally Brookfield residents to oppose the building of a mosque in Brookfield.

As Ms. Linnane reported, members of the Brookfield-Elm Grove Interfaith Council and the Milwaukee Islamic Society also attended the meeting held at the Brookfield Library. As reported, what started out as a discussion concerning zoning and traffic issues soon became a debate over religious and political ideology. One of the things I took away from reading the piece is that the Eagle Forum led residents were not only apprehensive about having a mosque in their community, but sounded as if they were actually frightened by such a possibility.

As a member of a religious and cultural minority, in my case Judaism; we are always reminded that we are a small minority in a much larger community. The Islamic community is no different and only represents an estimated 12 to 15 thousand in the entire Milwaukee Metro area. That’s even smaller than the Jewish Community. Keeping in mind that we are such small minorities we fully understand our vulnerabilities, but by and large we go about our business free from molestation from the majority.

However, since 9/11 the Muslin communities have drawn special attention and the majority of it has been negative.

I can’t hardly go online or pick up some piece of media print without a story about Muslims with a good share of it being highly inflammatory and directed toward citizens to be beware of Islam and their conspiracy to change our nation to some sort of Islamic theocracy.

The issue du jour is currently the imposition of Sharia Law. Christian fundamentalists and Christian fundamentalist clergy are attempting to incite public opinion against Islam because there is a supposed concerted attempt by Muslims to modify US law and to incorporate Sharia Law. What are presented are the most extreme incidences of Sharia such as Honor Killings, female mutilation, and extreme paternalism and misogyny. Strange that for them to cite these examples, they search the world and most of the incidences are very isolated. One must remember, just as Christianity is not a single doctrine, dogma and theology; neither is Islam. It is open to interpretation and some choose to interpret it more rigidly and others more liberally.

To label Islam with only one label, is a great disservice and minimizes the richness of their thought, religion and the culture.

I think the greatest source of fear and apprehension comes from the Christian majority’s lack of knowledge and understanding of Islam. Muslims represent the “other” in our society. Just as Jews have always represented the ever present “other” in Christian society; Muslims, unlike assimilated Jews, are relative newcomers to North America.

Up until 1993, with the first bombing of the World Trade Center, Muslims represented one of the background minorities that made up the crazy quilt of American society. Except in the largest metropolitan areas, most people never had seen a Muslim, let alone met one. Rarer still was finding anyone who actually knew Muslims and had interpersonal relationships with them. Much of the perception of Muslims and Islam in general has been generated by the media, most of which has always been associated with negative news reports and narratives.

It is very much part of human nature to be wary of the stranger and foreigner. We live in a society that is dominated by ethnocentrism, typically manifested as “we” and “they." Under normal circumstances, the first generation of immigrants hold the status of the foreigner with each succeeding generation becoming more assimilated resulting in eventual acceptance as one of “us."

However, with practicing Muslims, they retain their uniqueness long after first and second generations and never quite shed the mantle of the foreigner. Ultraorthodox Jewish groups also experience the same phenomena. The culture and significance is manifested by looking different, following unique and foreign customs, and remaining isolated by remaining closely grouped together. Islam and Judaism, which share Semitic roots and are of oriental origins, center themselves around the family and their cultural community. This tendency to remain isolated doesn’t make it easy for the outsider to create normal relationships.

As Muslim communities grow and expand beyond their initial cultural communities, there will be more and more contact between the Muslim and the non-Muslim. It is up to the majority to reach out and normalize relations with the new residents to their communities. If this is not done, continuing tensions will remain and the distrust will in time give way to hatred. Hatred will eventually lead to radicalization, which in its own terms leads to the kind of violence that we all want to avoid and fear.

I call on those with the power to end this campaign of dehumanization and distrust.

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Nancy Hall March 22, 2012 at 06:46 AM
You think Unitarians are extreme? Harvard University was founded by Unitarians. Four American presidents were Unitarians (Adams, Adams, Fillmore and Taft) and a fifth (Jefferson) was closely aligned with Unitarianism. That's more than 10% of U.S. Presidents following an "extreme" religion. It was once one of the dominant religions of New England and its roots are Christian. The difference between Unitarianism and other Christian religions was rejection of the Trinity, Of course we're talking about a time in America, unlike today, when religious tolerance was valued and the Constitution was regarded as the law of the land.
Nancy Hall March 22, 2012 at 06:50 AM
We're talking about something that happened 1,400 years ago.
Lyle Ruble March 22, 2012 at 12:43 PM
@J.B. Schmidt...Sorry about the error. No, Huffington has given me orders to change your name. A long debate has been going on in Judaism concerning Abraham and the other patriarchs. As I stated before there is no verification whether or not he and the other patriarchs actually existed or are simply archetypes. In either case it doesn't matter, because the evolvement of Judaism is not contingent on who Abraham was or was not. The Torah wasn't written down until probably somewhere around 800 B.C.E. and the first mention of a scroll was with Ezra the Scribe. There is a great deal unknown and much is based on tradition and conjecture. We do know that written and oral Torah emerged after the Babylonian diaspora. Also to emerge with the Babylonian diaspora were other traditions not thought to be part of the early Mosaic traditions, such as: the celebration of Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur. My point is that it is very cloudy as to the origins of Judaism, Christianity and Islam. One thing to be said is that the Qur'an was being written down while Mohammad was still alive. As far as the connection from Abraham through Ishmael to Mohammad, this is documented in the Torah through Ishmael and Abraham's other wives and concubines. When Moses meets Jethro, he is a priest of Median and they attributed their line back to Abraham. the Medianites were people of the Arabian Peninsula and clearly were Bedouin tribes. Abraham was the mythological fountainhead of many people.
Lyle Ruble March 22, 2012 at 01:01 PM
@J.B. Schmidt...Mohammad was a traveler being a caravan driver. He would have come into contact with a number of different groups. In Medina there was a large indigenous Jewish community and Mohammad would have been very familiar with them. Therefore, he would have had plenty of opportunity to learn about both Judaism and Christianity, and Islamic thought would have been influenced by the two other traditions and the accepted tenets of the time. Heavily influencing Islam was the tribal system. We even see that social structure at play today in Islamic societies. Islam became the unifying force that put an end to chronic tribal warfare. The problem for Islam is that they are locked into the 7th century and have not successfully fully transitioned to the 21st century.
Rolando Peabody March 27, 2012 at 12:10 AM
One thing we religious fanatics all have in common - we don't care for the gays.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »